You’ve noticed something off about your friend lately. He seems distracted when you bring up girls, dodges invites to clubs, and makes flimsy excuses to avoid blind dates. You start to wonder—is he actually into men and just pretending to be straight?
Before jumping to conclusions, look for these subtle signs.
His Mannerisms And Speech Patterns
The way he acts and talks can reveal a lot. Does he light up around guys but seem stiff around women? Does he have a slightly higher-pitched voice or a lisp? Stereotypes aside, these can be clues.
Watch his posture and walk—swaggering or more feminine gestures might hint at his true self.
Listen for how he talks about relationships. If he rarely mentions women or uses vague terms like “someone” instead of “girlfriend,” he might be keeping things vague on purpose.
Also, notice if he’s too into his appearance. Some closeted men overcompensate by being hyper-masculine or obsessively groomed to “prove” they’re straight.
And pay attention to how he talks about other guys. Casual comments like, “He’s got a great build,” or lingering compliments might slip through.
How He Interacts With Other Men
When a guy is pretending to be straight, he might seem awkward or nervous around men—especially straight ones. Does he avoid eye contact, stiffen up during guy talk, or dodge physical contact?
Another red flag? If he drops homophobic remarks or gay slurs around other men. Ironically, some closeted guys do this to deflect suspicion.
His Relationships With Women
Short-lived flings, zero interest in dating, or excuses like “I’m too busy for a relationship” can be telling. Even if he does date women, he might seem emotionally distant or avoid physical affection.
Some even marry or have kids to “prove” they’re straight—but their partners often feel confused by their lack of genuine connection.
His Grooming And Style
A guy who spends way too much time on his looks might be hiding something. Look for:
- Always-perfect hair, designer clothes, and keeping up with fashion trends.
- Obsessive gym routines (beyond just staying fit).
- Regular manicures, facials, or spa treatments—stuff most straight guys don’t prioritize.
- Subtle makeup or heavy cologne use.
- Flirty body language around men (lingering eye contact, playful touches).
- Passion for stereotypically “gay” interests (fashion, pop divas, RuPaul’s Drag Race).
One or two things? Maybe he’s just vain. But a combo of these? Worth noting.
Where His Eyes Go
Does he sneak glances at guys when he thinks no one’s looking? A quick check-out is normal, but if he’s constantly eyeing muscular men or the cute waiter, he might not be as straight as he claims.
Defensiveness About His Sexuality
If he freaks out when someone jokes about him being gay—getting angry, overly macho, or listing his “conquests”—that’s a red flag. Secure straight guys usually laugh it off.
Same if he makes homophobic comments. Sometimes, the loudest critics are hiding something themselves.
More Female Friends Than Male Friends
Women often create a more emotionally open and supportive dynamic, which is why many gay men—especially those still in the closet—naturally gravitate toward female friendships. With women, there’s less pressure to “perform” traditional masculinity or keep up a tough-guy act. Instead, these friendships thrive on shared interests, trust, and genuine connection without the unspoken rules of male bonding.
So if a guy only surrounds himself with women, refers to them as his “girlfriends” in a platonic way, or seems visibly more at ease in their company than with male peers… he might be hiding more than just his social preferences.
Social Media Habits
Check who he follows:
- Tons of shirtless fitness models or male influencers?
- Gay celebrities, LGBTQ+ activists, or hashtags like #Pride?
- Flirty comments on guys’ posts but radio silence on women’s?
His likes and DMs can be very telling.
Being Overly Defensive About His Masculinity
If a guy gets weirdly defensive or aggressive when his masculinity or sexuality is questioned – even jokingly – it could be a sign he’s hiding something.
- Does he overcompensate by constantly talking about how many girls he’s dated or hooked up with?
- Does he make a point of leering at or catcalling women to seem virile?
- Does he put down gay men or make homophobic comments?
These behaviors suggest he feels threatened by being perceived as effeminate or gay. Rather than risk being found out, he hides behind a mask of hypermasculinity. But over time, the act becomes exhausting and the mask starts to slip. His discomfort around the topic of homosexuality and his hostility toward gay people may stem from repressed feelings he can’t acknowledge even to himself.
Browsing History
Frequent visits to gay dating sites, forums, or a very clean search history could mean he’s hiding his tracks.
Forced Stories About Women
If he’s always recounting exaggerated “hookups” or ex-girlfriends in a way that feels rehearsed, he might be trying too hard to sell a story.
Strong Reaction To LGBTQ+ Topics
Does he get weirdly angry or uncomfortable when gay topics come up? Sometimes, homophobia is a cover for repressed feelings.
Denial… Over And Over
Think about it—if someone falsely accused you of something, you’d shrug it off. But if he keeps denying it unprompted? That’s suspicious.
Rejecting Gender Roles
Not all gay men do this, but some avoid “typical guy” stuff like sports, manual labor, or aggression. Instead, they lean into creativity, fashion, or gentler hobbies.
He’s Not Interested In Physical Intimacy
If he’s always “too tired” for physical closeness, it might mean his attraction lies elsewhere.
He’s “Overly” Masculine aka. Macho
When a guy is extra aggressive about his masculinity (think: nonstop chest-hair bragging), it can scream overcompensation.
Observe How He Holds A Glass or A Mug
Ever notice how someone holds their drink? Some say there’s a subtle—and surprisingly consistent—difference in grip between queer and straight folks. Many lesbian women tend to cradle their glass near the rim, fingers resting lightly at the top. Meanwhile, gay men often opt for a firmer hold, whether hooking a thumb into the glass’s indent, balancing it by the stem, or cupping it snugly in their palm. It’s one of those quiet, unspoken tells—like a shared wink across the room.
Sitting Position
A lot of gay men will sit with their legs crossed or close together instead of sprawling out. So if your friend tends to sit that way, it could maybe be a little hint…but then again, probably not! We can’t assume anything for sure based on one small thing. But if you’re trying to figure out your guy’s sexuality, you may want to add how they sit to the list of things to pay attention to.
Final Thoughts
No single sign is proof, but if multiple fit, there’s a chance he’s not being honest with himself—or you. The best approach? Create a safe space for him to open up if he’s ready.
More LGBT Content
The 5 Gayest Zodiac Signs Revealed: Are You One of Them?
8 Subtle And Hard-To-Spot Signs She’s A Femme Lesbian
